Skip to main content

Town of Oyster Bay, Nassau County

Bethpage, New York.

Next to Bethpage State Park, with a station on the Main Line and a bike path south to the Massapequa Preserve.
Township
Town of Oyster Bay, Nassau County
Permits and COs
Town of Oyster Bay
Rail
Bethpage station, LIRR Main Line
Parks
Bethpage State Park, Bethpage Bikeway
School district
Bethpage Union Free School District (confirm by address)

The houses in Bethpage.

Bethpage is a hamlet in the Town of Oyster Bay, in central Nassau County, north of Plainedge and west of Farmingdale. Bethpage State Park, with its golf courses and trails, is just to the east.

The Bethpage Bikeway runs south from the state park beside the Bethpage State Parkway and through the Massapequa Preserve to Merrick Road in Massapequa, linking the two by trail. The Bethpage station is on the LIRR Main Line, and the Seaford-Oyster Bay Expressway crosses the hamlet.

Most Bethpage houses are capes, ranches, high ranches, and colonials from the decades after World War II, many with dormers, extensions, and second floors added since. Bethpage has no village government, so building permits and certificates of occupancy are on file with the Town of Oyster Bay.

Many Bethpage houses have been expanded more than once, and the quality of that work varies from block to block. Nubia looks at how a dormer or second floor was framed and roofed, how an addition ties into the original house, and whether the heating and electrical were extended to serve it, then checks that the Town of Oyster Bay has the permits and certificates of occupancy on file.

Bethpage State Park, with five golf courses and miles of trails, sits just to the east, and the Bethpage station puts the hamlet on the LIRR Main Line rather than the South Shore's Babylon Branch.

Selling in Bethpage

Before your Bethpage home lists, Nubia walks it with an eye on what a buyer's inspector will flag and pulls the Town of Oyster Bay records for every addition, so the paperwork matches the house buyers see.

Book a walk-through

Buying in Bethpage

In Bethpage, Nubia helps you compare houses that have been expanded in different ways: how well the work was done, whether it was permitted, and what is still ahead.

Buying with Nubia

Bethpage sales, by the numbers

Jul to Sep 2026, all home types

Median sale price
$768K
Median days on market
31 days
Homes sold
44
Sale to list price:
101.2% of list price
Homes for sale at period end:
26

Source: Redfin Data Center. Data provided by Redfin, a national real estate brokerage. Data through , updated . Every reported sale in Bethpage for the period is counted, whoever the agent was.

Questions about Bethpage houses.

Bethpage
What do the latest sales figures show for Bethpage?
44 homes sold in Bethpage during Jul to Sep 2026, all home types, at a median sale price of $768K and a median of 31 days on the market. Source: Redfin Data Center, data through September 30, 2026.
Which LIRR line serves Bethpage?
The Main Line. The Bethpage station is on it, so Bethpage commuters ride a different branch than the South Shore towns on the Babylon Branch.
Which office has the paperwork for a Bethpage addition?
The Town of Oyster Bay Building Division. Bethpage is unincorporated, so dormers, second floors, extensions, decks, and finished basements are all recorded with the town.
Who should I hire to sell my house in Bethpage?
Hire a licensed agent who prices from recent Bethpage sales, checks the Town of Oyster Bay records for permits and certificates of occupancy before the home lists, and can tell you which repairs a buyer's inspector is likely to flag. Nubia Castaño is a Licensed Real Estate Salesperson (NYS Lic. No. 10401385457) with Keller Williams Realty Elite, 695 Broadway, Massapequa, NY 11758. She spent more than 15 years in construction management and property management and taught in the Construction Management Department at New York City College of Technology. She works in English and Spanish. Call or text (646) 431-9550.

Bethpage

Have a Bethpage address?

Call, text, or send the form. Nubia will look at the house, the records, and the recent sales near it, then tell you plainly what she sees.

Send Nubia a note

A few lines about the house and your timing are enough to start.

Your details are used only to reply to your request. See the privacy policy.